Former New York Residents Are Also Receiving Energy Rebate Checks
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul
Abu Sabet: The bill for the chicken salad, pasta, beer and a strawberry daiquiri that Nathan Walker and his date ran up at a farm-to-table restaurant last month was $100. "I was a little upset at how much money I spent," said Walker, a 29-year-old Chemung County native.
But relief came the next day: A one-time energy rebate check from New York state arrived in the mail - coincidentally for the exact same amount as his fancy dinner nearly 5,000 miles away in Honolulu.
Walker's story underscores how a $1 billion initiative that Gov. Kathy Hochul pushed in response to elevated energy costs is sending potentially tens of thousands of checks across state lines. It also speaks to the difficulty of administering such rebate programs, which some critics on both the left and right say aren't a good use of government money.
Walker, who now lives in Hawaii, said he thought it was strange. "I definitely don't think I have any claim to any kind of money from taxpayers," he said. "Thanks, Kathy, for my Friday evening."
Darren Dopp, a spokesman for the state Department of Taxation and Finance, said the "vast majority of power check recipients are current New York residents." The checks, which are still being sent, were dispatched to income-eligible individuals who were full-time New York residents in 2024 and filed a tax return for that year.
The program gives $200 to joint filers with incomes under $150,000 or $150 to joint filers with incomes between $150,000 and $300,000. Single filers with incomes under $150,000 receive $100 in the mail. Hochul said it was a response to elevated utility and gasoline prices.
"When you live in upstate New York in particular, the bills are really high," Hochul said in September. "I know $200 isn't going to magically change your lives … we hear their concerns, we're trying to do what we can."
"You don't have to do a thing," she added. "No application. No paperwork. No hoops to jump through - if you're eligible, the check is coming to you." Hochul spokeswoman Kristin Devoe said the state has sent 7 million of the estimated 8.2 million rebate checks. The mailings began in September and are expected to wrap up next month. Devoe said the program was designed to rapidly put money in people's pockets, and said former residents are legally entitled to the payments.
Officials wouldn't say exactly how many checks went out of state, but taxpayer migration data reviewed by the Times Union suggest it could be tens of thousands of people.
More than 112,000 individuals and families who would have fit those requirements left the state in 2024, the most recent year on record, according to figures provided by the state comptroller's office. The comptroller's figures show between 120,000 and 175,000 tax filers in the eligible brackets left in each of the preceding five years. Data for 2025 and 2026 aren't available.
The Times Union identified taxpayers in New Jersey and Texas who fit the same pattern as Walker. They left the Empire State in 2025, 2026 or late in 2024 but had filed tax returns for that full year. Ken Girardin, a fellow at the conservative Manhattan Institute, said that shows the program was sloppily conceived.
"This is one of the many reasons why this quote-unquote rebate should never have happened," he said.
Girardin argued that the state could have directly credited New Yorkers' utility bills, which he said would have slashed expenses and ensured that the state was only helping current residents. New York has some of the highest residential electricity bills in the country.
Devoe said that kind of system would require the state to send money to utility companies and wouldn't capture New Yorkers whose utility costs are included in their rent. Lawmakers approved the rebate check program as part of this year's state budget, which Hochul signed in May.
But critics panned the rebate checks as a political maneuver in the months leading up to the midterms. They said the effort was aimed at boosting Democrats' electoral odds by putting cash in the pockets of potential voters, though the state also carried out a similar relief program last year in response to cost-of-living concerns. Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, Hochul's Republican challenger, likened the checks to peanuts compared to the high price of energy. Hochul defeated him earlier this month by around 20 percentage points.
Emily Eisner, executive director of the left-leaning Fiscal Policy Institute, said the money the state spent on the rebate checks would have been put to better use on building energy infrastructure. She said the check program was a wasteful Band-Aid that was difficult and costly to administer.
Dopp, the tax department spokesman, acknowledged in emails that the agency's processing team is "slammed" and "busy" with the mailings. But he also wrote that the program is "all being handled with existing resources."
James Wetzler, the state's tax commissioner from 1988 to 1994, said the administrative costs likely amount to a small portion of the taxpayer money that has been earmarked for the program. Wetzler also argued that the tax department has a lighter workload during this time of year, when the agency's staffers are less busy than around the April 15 filing deadline.
Walker said his check had been delivered to his father's residence in Delaware. That's where the father and son had moved in 2024 before the younger Walker moved several months later to Hawaii. He now works as a high school teacher and has no plans to return.
"I have no business in New York. I haven't for a long time," Walker said. "I haven't set foot there well over two years now."
*Copyright 2026 Bangla Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
BP/SM
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
Canada is turning toward China to cope with US tariff pressure.
Trump wants to hold a meeting with Kim: US Secretary of State
New Indigenous Group Emerges from the Depths of the Amazon Rainforest
Sangeet Academy